Pie in your face: Three business disasters to avoid


Group Colleges Australia founder and chief executive officer Alan Manly. Source: Supplied.

Business disasters come in all shapes, sizes and industries. There are many famous examples — think Enron, Blockbuster and Dick Smith.

Businesses can be vulnerable to disaster at any stage, but startup and expansion phases are particularly risky.

While the failure of a business is a disaster for those involved, it’s a great learning opportunity for other entrepreneurs. Here are three business disasters to avoid.

1. Starbucks in Australia

Despite being well established in the United States, Starbucks’ expansion into Australia didn’t go so well. Aussies love their coffee, so surely the Seattle-based company would be welcomed with open arms. The decision-makers at Starbucks certainly thought so, with nearly 90 Australian stores opened from 2000 to 2008. Gartner’s Thomas O’Connor put Starbucks’ Australian failure down to a rushed expansion.

“When they launched, they launched too rapidly and they didn’t give the Australian consumer the opportunity to really develop an appetite for the Starbucks brand,” O’Connor said.

They saw scaling as the panacea for success ⁠— and being a global company with plenty of cash, they could afford to absorb the losses, which only kept them hurtling down the same disastrous route.

Either Australian customers were too slow to realise what they needed in coffee (unlikely), or Starbucks should have launched fewer stores and listened to their customers before scaling up. In 2008, Starbucks was forced to close 70% of its Australian locations. An avoidable disaster.  

The lesson

Once the product is launched, the clock is ticking. If customers have not accepted the new product, an urgent revision of the assumptions behind the KPIs would be wise. Even really successful entrepreneurs have learnt to accept what the market says as reality.

2. Pie Face

Founded in 2003, Pie Face is a chain of pie and coffee retailers which experienced rapid growth in Australia and overseas. Unfortunately, mounting debts forced it into liquidation in 2014, resulting in the closure of most of its stores. Franchisees were overspending on rent to occupy CBD hotspots, putting extra financial pressure on them to break even. The company owed money to every one of its landlords.

Pie Face is a lesson in what happens when entrepreneurs turn a blind eye to cashflow problems and ignore mounting debt.

Cashflow is something a business owner simply cannot ignore, and one of Australia’s most famous entrepreneurs is known for being obsessive about it. As referenced in the book Murdoch: The Making of a Media Empire, Rupert Murdoch was “interested, above all, in cashflow”.

While it may sound a little soulless, by taking a leaf out of Murdoch’s book, you can avoid the humiliation of a Pie Face-esque collapse.

The lesson

Naturally, entrepreneurs fall in love with their idea, be it a service or a product. The actual product itself can become the centre of attention. Stepping back would reveal an entrepreneur must always remember it is the business model that’s important and the business must pay its way.

3. Masters

All startups could do with a bit more money behind them. But imagine starting a business, effectively a startup, with a whopping $3 billion in funding. That’s essentially what Masters did, launching into the Australian market like a runaway train before its new board chair slammed the brakes on.

According to AFR, the expansion was “strangled by a hard-headed new Woolworths board led by Scotsman Gordon Cairns, who simply couldn’t stomach tipping any more funds into the Masters hardware chain, after $3 billion-plus had leaked into the drains outside its 63 stores across Australia”.

Critics pointed to the Australian market being different to the US, and suggested Masters had stocked too many products Australians didn’t want to buy from hardware stores, including washing machines and vacuum cleaners.

Its early marketing and store designs were deliberately aimed at women, alienating hordes of tradesmen who stayed loyal customers at Bunnings. Had Masters spent more time understanding what Australian consumers wanted from a home improvement store before investing billions, perhaps this disaster could have been avoided.

The lesson

Persistence can sometimes be confused with ego. Committing to a business model, with everyone who knows you watching, can unwittingly lock you into a dismissive response to any pragmatic suggestion of a major rethink. Be bold and learn to listen.

Not every business will end up like these, but to avoid disaster, you’ve got to be smart and pragmatic.

As American comedian WC Fields said: “If at first you don’t succeed, try, try again. Then quit. There’s no point in being a damn fool about it.”

NOW READ: Iconic Aussie brand Dick Smith Foods to shut down: Smith says Aldi and Amazon are to blame

NOW READ: Spotlight claims 19 Masters development sites as the hardware chain enters final days


Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

To lump Blockbuster and Dick Smith in with the likes of Pie Face and Starbucks is just wrong.
The latter two were poorly planned and executed yes, from the get go.
However the former two were absolutely functional and successful at the time. Time and technology saw the demise of Blockbuster, and Dick Smith which was very successful was killed off by Abboud as can be read in material available.