Melbourne lighting design company Mance Design has accused Country Road of ripping off its store fitout and lighting designs.
Mance Design is based in Richmond, just down the road from Country Road’s headquarters, and co-owner Dean Gaylor claims Country Road ripped off many of the concepts in sketches Mance Design prepared for Country Road and in particular Mance Design’s well known “Hedgehog” lamp.
Get business news first
Sign up to SmartCompany’s daily newsletter
“It does grate on you at the end of the day you think these guys got away with it,” Gaylor says.
“They claim to be about Australian design but they’re not really.”
Mance Design’s studio has roller doors at the front and in warm weather the business opens up the roller doors so everyone can see inside.
“On a few occasions people from Country Road asked if they could come in and ask if they can come around,” Gaylor says.
Gaylor claims that in early August 2008, a team from Country Road including Heilam Choy, creative manager of visual merchandising and Mark VanTatenhove, store design and planning co-ordinator, came in to visit Mance Design’s studio.
Choy is well known in the design community posting as “@thedesignhoarder” on Pinterest and Instagram with over 150,000 Pinterest followers.
They discussed concepts for Country Road’s Doncaster and Chadstone stores and provided Mance Designs with shop drawings and also visual boards for store décor.
“They particularly liked one product, our hedgehog light, it’s a spherical form that’s sculpted like a noxious weed,” Gaylor says.
Choy asked Mance Designs what it could come up with and do with a budget of $20,000 for one installation suspended from the ceiling.
Mance Designs’ original drawing of the installation above, and Country Road’s version below.
Mance Designs then emailed rough estimates of costings and also three options in a written format.
Choy requested visual sketches to illustrate these concepts and Mance Designs emailed six conceptual sketch drawings illustrating Mance Design’s ideas.
“We designed a number of installations but they were very loosely sketched as we were cautious that nothing had been paid for”, Gaylor says.
“We exchanged a few emails then the emails just stopped.”
The Mance Design team were unable to get hold of anyone at Country Road until in late September, Gaylor’s former business partner, Christopher Boutsinis, telephoned Choy to ask what had happened with the project, and was told that it had been shelved.
“Some time later we got phone calls from people who said have you just done the fit out for Country Road?,” Gaylor says.
Mance Design’s owners were then surprised to walk past Country Road’s, South Yarra store and see “heinous” rip offs of the concepts provided to Country Road earlier, and also replicas of Mance’s Hedgehog light.
“They pretty much copied our product, the Hedgehog, as closely as they probably could,” Gaylor says.
Mance Designs’ ‘Hedgehog’ above, and Country Road’s version below
Country Road then used this fit out and display for all its flag ship stores across the country.
“The biggest concern we had, was that people who knew our work and who had seen these installations, believed we had been responsible for these works,” he says.
“County Road has clearly copied the idea in its form and overall aesthetics, yet failed to deliver on the quality, hence we feel this diluted both the quality of our brand and our work.”
Mance Design approached Country Road with its claims of copying and sent an invoice to Country Road for design fees, totalling $2,420.
Boutsinis received a telephone call from Choy in response who said “We could not afford any alternatives… so we decided to have our own workshop and create our own concepts”.
Mance Design told Country Road it would undertake legal action within seven days if the invoice was not paid but Choy then sent an email refuting any assertion that the work was copied, referenced or in any way borrowed from Mance Design.
Mance Designs sought legal advice but decided the costs and time involved in pursuing Country Road were better spent on building their business.
“We spent $10,000 [in legal fees] without handing Country Road a letter,” Gaylor says.
“We thought how much will this cost to get Country Road into court? We are a small business and we don’t have silver lined pockets to really fight Country Road.”
Gaylor says as a small business the Mance Design team decided to put their effort and energy into creating new designs.
“We’re not as trusting now,” Gaylor says.
“We were pretty young and naïve then.”
Now when people come in and ask for samples or sketches Gaylor says Mance Designs often just says no.
“Sometimes we feel that it comes at the cost of a job.”
Sacha Laing, chief operating officer of Country Road, told SmartCompany he could not comment on the claims as they were too long ago.
Laing says Country Road works hard to ensure the integrity of its designs.