When is a Google review considered defamatory?

online reviews defamation

Madgwicks Lawyers special counsel Catherine Ballantyne. Source: supplied.

Bad Google reviews can make or break a business, with a single negative comment enough to turn away a potential customer or client. With some reviews being snarling, negative attacks, it raises the question of whether such a public display of negativity is defamation.

So, when is a Google review considered defamatory? What is the line between someone sharing their honest opinion in the review and that review becoming defamatory? 

What is defamation?

Defamation occurs when a statement is published (and is seen by at least one person) and could be considered to have lowered the reputation of the mentioned person or business in the eyes of the public. 

Google reviews are therefore ripe for defamation claims, with negative reviews often viewed by multiple people online, which can have a considerable effect on the reputation of the reviewee. 

Who can make a claim for defamation?

Not everyone can claim they have been defamed. The only parties who can commence a defamation action are:

  • A living person (proceedings cannot be brought by or continued on behalf of a deceased estate);
  • A not-for-profit corporation; and
  • A small corporation with fewer than 10 employees.

If the review was not made against one of these types of people or businesses, it is not possible to start a defamation claim. 

It is important to note a person or business does not need to be specifically named in the Google review for it to be defamatory. The person only needs to be identifiable by the description in the review, such as ‘the Prime Minister of Australia’, ‘the owner of the local McDonalds’ or the ‘shoe shop on Smith Street’. 

It may also be defamatory if there is a reference to a class of people. For example: ‘All the shop assistants at shop XYZ are …’.

Are there defences to defamation? 

Yes! The two most common defences are truth and honest opinion.

Truth defence

If the claims made in the Google review are true, you cannot claim defamation. This is a complete defence to any allegations. 

Honest opinion defence

A person is entitled to publish an honest opinion in their Google review and this cannot be considered defamation. If the person writing the Google review honestly held the opinion and this opinion is based on truth, this is a defence against defamation. Honesty is crucial — it doesn’t need to be proven that the opinion was correct, only that it was genuinely held.

However, even if this honest opinion defence is established, it can still be overcome and the Google review considered defamatory if it can be shown:

  • the author of the review did not honestly hold the opinion;
  • the defamed person or the business has grounds to believe the reviewer did not honestly hold their opinion; or
  • the review was left maliciously to negatively affect the business or satisfy a grudge.

Conclusion

If you believe you have been defamed on the internet or social media, you should seek legal advice on the merits of your claim as soon as possible after the material is published.

Often, a letter from a lawyer putting the offending parties on notice is sufficient for the removal of the review. 

NOW READ: Can you be sued for what other people write on your Facebook page?

NOW READ: Childcare business ordered to pay $237,000 after defaming former employee

COMMENTS

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
4 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Kishor Lalwani
Kishor Lalwani
1 year ago

great info, can google be included in the defamatory action since they are the publsher

Chris
Chris
1 year ago
Reply to  Kishor Lalwani

No. Now look for an honest line of work.

Kristen
Kristen
6 months ago

My interest was piqued after reading the reasons why a review on Google could be considered legally defamatory. I would like help finding resources such as a lawyer who specializes in this type of issue. Please let me know— thank you!

Vivian Rathgeber
Vivian Rathgeber
3 months ago

After giving a negative review of one restaurant, the owner of the restaurant did some research and discovered my former employer. To my surprise, my ex manager called me, intimidated me and demanded that I withdraw my comment, on top of that she threatened me, saying that if any company seeks her out to get references about me, she won’t do it. This is so absurd! I was devastated! It was really intimidated, but my opinion at the review exposes what I feel and I respect that they are allowed to refused who is not vaccinated. And we left the place. No big deal. I only wrote that I don’t agree with this. Really, what amazed me the most was the audacity of the owner of this restaurant to seek out my ex-manager to intimidate me. 
This is unacceptable! Unbelievable!
Am I wrong?
Can they tracked me, and ask a third person to intimidate me and threatened me?

Close
SmartCompany Plus

Sign in

To connect a sign in method the email must match the one on your SmartCompany Plus account.
Or use your email
Show
Forgot your password?

Want some assistance?

Contact us on: support@smartcompany.com.au or call the hotline: +61 (03) 8623 9900.