close
  • Business Advice
    • Franchising
    • Innovation
    • Intellectual Property
    • Legal
    • Politics
    • Strategy
  • Finance
    • Cashflow
    • Economy
    • Funding
    • Tax
    • Superannuation
  • Marketing
    • Advertising
    • Sales
    • Social Media
  • People & Human Resources
    • Industrial Relations
    • Leadership
    • Managing
    • Mental health & wellbeing
    • Recruitment & Hiring
    • Training & Development
    • Workplace Health & Safety
  • Entrepreneurs
    • Influencers & Profiles
  • Partner Content
    • Articles
    • Article Series
    • eBooks
    • Webinars
    • Point of Sale
    • Pilot Light
  • Watch & Listen
  • Events & Training
  • Smart50 Awards
  • International Women’s Day
  • Subscribe
  • StartupSmart
    • StartupSmart
    • Startup News & Analysis
    • Startup Advice
    • Subscribe Startup Smart
  • About Us
  • Advertise
  • Code-of-Conduct
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • instagram
  • youtube
SmartCompany
  • SmartCo
    • Business Advice
    • Influencers & Profiles
  • StartupSmart
    • StartupSmart News and Analysis
    • StartupSmart Advice
  • Lists
  • Partner Content
  • Events & Training
  • Subscribe
Search
Funding

Wonga enters administration: Payday loans sector reform catching up to lenders in Britain

The Conversation / Tuesday, September 4, 2018

payday loans

The spotlight is on Wonga. Source: Shutterstock.

By Lindsey Appleyard, Coventry University

Wonga, the poster-boy of the British payday lending industry, has gone into administration following an influx of customer compensation claims. Its demise is a result of government regulation to reform the payday loans sector in favour of the consumer.

A price cap that was introduced by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) regulator in 2015 on high-cost, short-term credit means that Wonga and other payday lenders’ history of irresponsible lending is catching up with them. Profits have been eaten into as a result of the cap, with Wonga having to foot the bill for a large number of compensation claims for loans taken out before the regulation was introduced. It is likely that as a result of the FCA’s ongoing reforms, other high-cost lenders will also collapse.

The experiences of payday loan applicants gives a sense of how significant this is. On the one hand, they include people who are in desperate need of credit, often to pay for bills. But, on the other, this leaves them vulnerable to paying a poverty premium.

Wonga’s rise

The rise of payday lending came about in the wake of the 2008 financial crash, which brought many households personal financial crises of their own. Household budgets across the board have been squeezed due to rising costs and wage freezes, with many now worse off than before the great recession.

One way to bridge the gap between income and outgoings is by using credit. For many, this means using mainstream bank finance in the form of overdrafts, loans or credit cards. But a growing number of households are unable to access mainstream bank finance and are excluded from mainstream options as a result of a low credit score or insecure employment.

High-cost credit in all its different forms (payday loans, home-collected credit, rent-to-buy, log-book loans) operates as an alternative credit market for those excluded from mainstream finance. Payday loans — and Wonga especially — were extremely popular due to the anonymity and ease of applying online and fast access to cash. But huge interest rates led to many paying dearly for this easy access to credit.

The new FCA regulation stopped some of the worst excesses. But, to remain competitive alongside the new regulation, payday lenders changed their operations and innovated new products. For example, some payday loan products have longer repayments terms. This, however, means that the loan is more expensive overall, even though repayments are more affordable.

People’s experiences

Alongside Carl Packmam (then at Toynbee Hall and now the Fair by Design campaign against the poverty premium), I undertook in-depth research with former payday loan takers who then self-identified as “declined applicants” as a result of the regulation. What we found was different to the FCA’s 2017 report which said that the majority of former users of payday loans (63%) that have since become a “declined applicant” as a result of the regulation “believe that they are better off as a result”. The FCA’s research indicated that 60% of “declined applicants” do not borrow from other sources and have not turned to other forms of high-cost credit or illegal money lenders.

Our interviews with 80 people who had been declined from a payday loan since the regulation was introduced suggest a more nuanced picture. Talking to people face-to-face, we went more in-depth than the FCA’s consumer survey and we found that people took a series of actions. They sought access to other credit after being declined, such as applying to another lender, friends and family. Some tried to avoid borrowing, such as by going without credit or increasing their working hours.

The most common step that people took after being declined was to access money from friends and family. The second was to apply for some other kind of formal credit product. Many of our interviewees were successful in accessing a payday loan from another company after being declined by one first. This suggests that some lenders are not adhering to responsible lending or the high-cost, short-term credit regulation and that the “declined applicant” status was temporary for some. Only four people borrowed from an ethical community finance lender (such as credit union or Community Development Finance Institution) and one used a credit card.

This signals to us that more borrowing options were preferable for declined applicants than managing in other ways. Or because the money was needed for essential items such as rent and utilities. This potentially strengthens the case for better and more affordable borrowing options for those now declined a payday loan.

We know credit is not always the solution to all borrower’s problems, but we also know that more affordable credit options would provide a lifeline for many people today who feel their only option is to use very expensive credit products. While the cap on the cost of payday loans has largely had the intended effect of increasing rules around what kind of borrower (and in what kind of situation) can manage using a payday loan with few risks of causing negative financial outcomes, there still needs to be a greater supply of alternative credit products available to fill that demand.

This article was originally published on The Conversation. Read the original article.

NOW READ: Administrators report Adriano Zumbo’s business “may have been insolvent” while still trading

NOW READ: “I had two hours”: When Jamie Oliver discovered his restaurant empire was falling apart

Advertisement
The Conversation

Contributors

  • LinkedIn engagement pods: Silver bullet or desperate ploy? Sue Parker DARE Group founder
  • Own it: The 10 things you need to do to manage your personal brand Lisa Stephenson Who Am I Projects founder
  • How to call your team into action with a winning presentation Emma Bannister Presentation Studio founder
  • The link between diet and mental health — and how to eat your way to wellbeing Kate Save Be Fit Food co-founder
  • From interactive videos to AI: The five marketing trends that will dominate 2019 Warwick Boulter Collaboro co-founder
  • Australia is leading the legaltech revolution, but what does this mean for lawyers, firms and clients? Jodie Baker Xakia founder
  • Why a video news release needs to be part of your PR strategy Leisa Goddard Adoni Media managing director
  • Want to catch more customers? Here's how to create a super sales funnel Jovana Vujnic Bumper Leads founder

Most Read

  1. Appster
    “Where did the money go?”: How Appster went from riches to ruin
  2. Accountant banned for three years following ASIC probe
  3. Permanent director IDs imminent as Parliament considers business registry reform
  4. Dinner deals startup Buddy scores Uber partnership after just six months of trading
  5. Toys ‘R’ Us sets sights on Australian relaunch after being resurrected from bankruptcy

Subscribe to SmartCompany

Free business news, analysis and advice, Monday to Friday

Partner Content

  • Articles

    The fall of the gig economy – and its impact on small businesses

  • Articles

    From profitable to struggling: Don’t let invoices go unpaid

  • Articles

    Productivity gains and less back pain: 3 simple tips for creating a healthier office

  • Articles

    Don’t be scared, be prepared: Embracing technology to future-proof family business

  • Webinars

    Webinar: Overcome the biggest SME challenges

SmartCompany is the leading online publication in Australia for free news, information and resources catering to Australia's entrepreneurs, small and medium business owners and business managers.

Monday to Friday, SmartCompany.com.au publishes news, business trends and ideas from around the world, profiles and features, as well as all the latest business, tax, legal, marketing, politics and innovation developments occurring around the country.

SmartCompany
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • linkedin
  • instagram
  • youtube
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Advertise
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Code-of-Conduct
  • Privacy Policy
  • Subscribe
  • Crikey
  • The Mandarin
  • StartupSmart
  • Bureau
  • Private Media
Copyright © 2019 Private Media Pty Ltd. Publishers of SmartCompany. All rights reserved.