“Should I buy now or wait?”: A property Q&A for first-home buyers and investors

mmortgage brokers

There is plenty of evidence that our property markets have changed.

The hot ‘sellers’ market’ we saw in the past few years, where vendors called the shots and the price of many properties increased at a dizzying rate, is now gone.

Now there are more properties for sale than there are buyers, because many buyers are becoming a little nervous and holding back with their purchase decisions.

We are now in a ‘buyers’ market’ — where home-owners and investors have the balance of power on their side.

So should you buy now or wait for prices to drop further? And which properties are likely to suffer most in a buyers’ market?

Let me answer these questions with a quick Q&A.

Q: What’s happening to property values around Australia?

The latest figures from Corelogic confirm that our housing markets are having a weak run, with dwelling prices falling in both capital cities and regional locations over the last quarter.

As you can see from the chart below, our property markets are fragmented, with Brisbane, Hobart, Adelaide and Canberra and the combined regional market still rising over the last year.

However, since peaking in September last year, the overall Australian housing market has recorded a cumulative 1.9% fall in value.  

Clearly, Australia’s housing markets are not performing anywhere near as badly as some of the scary headlines would suggest.

In fact, we’re experiencing a relatively mild downturn considering that nationally house prices are still 31% higher than they were five years ago.


Q: Are house prices likely to fall further, and if so, how long will this weakness last?

What happens next will be dependent on the availability of finance and on consumer confidence.

The availability of credit is unlikely to improve until next year which, together with the negative media headlines appearing on a daily basis, is likely to dampen consumer confidence.

I predict property values in some locations of Sydney and Melbourne likely will keep falling until next year.

However, while the value of some properties may fall a further 5% in some locations, home values are holding their own, and even increasing, in other areas.

In other words, our two big property markets are exhibiting a soft landing.

The Perth property market is likely to bottom out in the next nine months, after more than four years of falling prices, but it’s recovery will be slow and values are unlikely to start increasing any time soon.

Hobart’s strong growth is likely to slow down over the next year and Brisbane will probably be the strongest property market over the next few years

Q: If I’m looking to get into property should I buy now or wait for prices to drop further?

While the markets have weakened, the supply of good properties has also decreased, meaning ‘A-grade’ homes and investment-grade properties are still holding their values — even in the weak Melbourne and Sydney property markets.

So rather than trying to time the market, if you’re a home buyer, your family needs should really dictate when you buy your property.

If you’re a first-home buyer specifically, it’s a great time to take advantage of the banks’ willingness to lend you money.

And if you’re an established home buyer, it’s a perfect time to trade up your home, which may be worth a little less today but so will the property you are buying.

On the other hand, if you’re an investor, the right time to buy is when you have the finance to do so and it fits in with your long-term plans.

Don’t try and time the market.

Think about it: it’s the first time in years that we’ve experienced a buyers’ market in Sydney and Melbourne, but this hasn’t changed the long-term outlook of the markets.

The fundamentals of strong population growth, a robust economy with excellent jobs creation and state government infrastructure spending will underpin a property market.

Q:  Which segments of the property market are likely to suffer the most in a buyer’s market?

Fortunately, we can learn lessons from the past.

Each quarter Core Logic releases its Pain and Gain Report giving insights into which type of properties are resold at a profit or loss.

While the vast majority (89.8%) of properties sold in Australia deliver their owners a profit, some trends have emerged:

  • About 10% of all properties sold sell at a gross loss for their owners;
  • Apartments were more likely to sell at a loss than houses, which is most likely due to the high premium many investors paid for their new unit;
  • In the last quarter, Melbourne units were 10 times more likely to re-sell at a loss than houses, which was much the same in Brisbane (9 times) and Canberra (8 times) but dissimilar from Sydney and Hobart where a greater proportion of units re-sold for a profit than houses; and
  • More regional properties sell at a loss than those in our capital cities.

Locations with a high supply of new apartment projects are likely to suffer due to significant oversupply. Examples of place that currently face an oversupply of apartments include the Brisbane CBD, Fortitude Valley, Paramatta, Harris Park, Homebush Zetland and Ryde.

It’s not a new idea, and I’ve said it often before, but it’s worth repeating: avoid off the plan properties as, on completion, a large proportion value in at considerably below their contract price.

I would also avoid locations where the residents are more likely to suffer from mortgage stress. These tend to be outer suburbs where young families have stretched their finances.

And, as always, I would steer clear of the many property spruikers disguised as investment advisers but who are actually working as project marketers for developers. They lure naïve investors in with their get-rich-quick schemes — but that’s not how property works.

As Warren Buffet said: “Wealth is the transfer of money from the impatient to the patient.”

Q:  What does this mean moving forward?

The key to property success is to buy well-located properties, as the location of your property will to do most of the ‘heavy lifting’ on the performance of your property.

While there are still many buyers in the market, there has been a ‘flight to quality’, with purchasers bypassing secondary properties.

Important factors for buyers are lifestyle and access to good public transport.

Getting around our big cities will not get any easier in the future and people will pay a premium to live in ‘walkable’ locations and near public transport

Q:  Do you have any other tips for buying well in a buyer’s market?

1. Firstly, don’t try and be smart and time the market — even the experts can’t time the market. But don’t rush in and make an emotional purchase. Instead, do careful research — not just online, but pound the pavement and get to know local prices, understand how the local market is behaving and make sure you don’t overpay. 

2. Now more than ever it is important to get a good team around you, including a proficient mortgage broker to help you through the maze of finance and the banks, and a buyers’ agent to help level the playing field when you’re in the thick of things against agents.

3. Don’t be scared to buy at auction — there is generally less competition nowadays.

4. Be prepared to buy before auction — but be careful. Currently, agents are trying to convince buyers to make pre-auction offers because they have only one or maybe two potential buyers for a property and they don’t want to conduct an auction where there isn’t competitive bidding. Of course, I understand why some purchasers like the idea of making a pre-auction offer — they see it as an opportunity to avoid competition on auction day. But sometimes what they’re really doing is overpaying because there is no competition. Think of it this way: if there was another buyer to compete with, the agent would be happy and eager to take the property to auction. 

5. Once you do buy a property, don’t compulsively follow property prices online. This will only lead to buyer’s remorse. Instead, be reassured by the long-term fundamentals that will support our property markets and the value of your property.

The bottom line

If you are considering investing or buying a new home, why not take advantage of the buyers’ market?

While experienced investors love these markets because they have more time to make decisions and can negotiate with more effect, it seems that many new investors or first-home buyers find it easier to decide not to buy.

Why is this?

I guess one reason is that in a sellers’ market, less-experienced investors gain comfort knowing everyone else is buying. The buying decision is so much easier when we see lots of others around us doing the same thing. We feel it must be a good decision.

Yet when it comes to making that decision to buy in one of these softer buyers’ markets, new investors or first-home buyers seem to think ‘I guess there must be something all those non-buyers know that I don’t know.’

I’ve found that when all the news in the media is positive, happy, self-assured people are comfortable making decisions to buy homes and cars. However, during times of uncertainty, or when we get bad news or mixed messages in the press, this does not breed ‘happy people’.

One thing is certain: we can’t accurately predict the peaks and troughs in the market.

But we can sit on the sidelines and wait until the market starts rising again and then compete with the new herd of confident buyers. But this will mean paying more. The bottom line is this will only be a buyer’s market for you if you buy.

As an investor, you need to take a long-term view, do your homework and research carefully to make sure you don’t overpay when you go out and buy that property today that you would have had to fight much harder for a few months ago.

NOW READ: State by state: An update on Australia’s housing markets


Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Randy Maloney
Randy Maloney
3 years ago

Property market is going down and there is little ammunition left to stop it

Michael M. Yardney
Michael M. Yardney
3 years ago
Reply to  Randy Maloney

You’re right Randy, the Sydney property market is falling a whopping 5.6% over the last year since rising over 70% since 2012. And the Melbourne market has dropped a significant 1.7% after rising over 50% since in the last cycle. What will underpinned our property values are our rising population and the economic strength of our country

Randy Maloney
Randy Maloney
3 years ago

I see they are still falling. It is not easy always being right…

3 years ago

There seems to be good value in Brisbane family homes in good central suburbs. Even in slightly tougher times, the prices can’t stay so comparatively low compared to Sydney and Melbourne.

Edith Flood
Edith Flood
3 years ago

Average mortgage: $400,000. Average monthly repayment P+I = around $2000 to $2500. Number of mortgagees under stress: one third of total. Recent adjustment by Fed of 1/4%, plus coming increases due to bond selloffs triggered by strong US economy, rising dollar means more mortgage stress, more Aussie defaults. Yet the real estate spruikers tell you it’s a great time to buy. No, we have the biggest property bubble in the entire world. When it pops, when Scott Morrison is forced to agree to a request to invoke the Financial Services (Crisis Resolution) Act 2018 which they snuck through the Senate with just seven senators present, when deposits are being bailed-in to save the banks… Under the powers in that very Act, then the PM will tell us it’s our civic duty to contribute to save the national economy. That will be a great time to buy property. Not now. The 2008 dead cat has taken a decade to bounce. It sure looked alive. But it isn’t healthy. Bailouts in 2008 by the US Govt and fiscal policy by Rudd put the banks on life support. Now they are in palliative care. Terminal case of unmitigated greed.

3 years ago

Do you think it’s a good time to consolidate investment portfolio in the current market? I got some investment property that made some money in the last cycle and now I want to diversify my portfolio and trade that with something in a different area. I won’t make top dollar from it compare with last year but in the mean time I can reduce my debt and improve my borrowing capacity for another possible opportunity in an area with more potential future growth. However CGT and stamp duty is holding me back. Any thought on that? Is it worth to do?

steve weingarth
steve weingarth
3 years ago

The media are brainwashing people that real estate is crashing-scaring off investors which will put rents up,and ruining the plans for those selling to retire with Super from house sales. Ruining real estate confidence undermines the economy as people reduce spending when their equity falls. its time for balance ,the correction should stop in Sydney and flatline for a while,not continue to fall in NSW- the strongest economy and population growth centre in the country. Just stop the self fulfilling gloom and doom talk in the media please! Steve

Randy Maloney
Randy Maloney
3 years ago

I noticed the falls gathered even more steam in November. I also noticed that this guy reckons that prices will turn the corner in 2019 LOL…

SmartCompany Plus

Sign in

To connect a sign in method the email must match the one on your SmartCompany Plus account.
Or use your email
Forgot your password?

Want some assistance?

Contact us on: support@smartcompany.com.au or call the hotline: +61 (03) 8623 9900.