Coles doesn’t want customers in its new “dark” store

Coles supermarket

Source: AAP Image/Paul Miller

By Anthony Colangelo

Supermarket giant Coles has opened its first online-only “dark store” in inner-city Melbourne with plans to expand into other population-dense areas.

Coles boss John Durkan told Wesfarmers’ annual strategy briefing on June 22 that his chain wanted more of the stores, which barred all shopping public and only contained dedicated staff picking and delivering stock to online consumers.

The opening came after Woolworths launched a similar store in Sydney in 2014.

An online consumer behaviour expert warned that any widespread move to “dark stores” (called such because of their dimmer lights) would alienate at least 50% of shoppers.

“If you look at shoppers in supermarkets, half will be ones who like to touch their products and the other half won’t,” Central Queensland University online shopping expert Dr En Li told The New Daily.

The push to online stores is an attempt by Coles to capitalise on an apparent thirst for online grocery shopping, Fairfax Media reported last week.

The new “dark store” is in the Melbourne suburb of Richmond.

Coles’ Online arm was “profitable, but not ragingly profitable”, according to Durkan.

The Richmond “dark store” serves a 5km radius in inner-city Melbourne.

He said the “only way I could see it working” would be for the stores to service high-density areas, Fairfax reported.

The Woolworths version in Mascot in Sydney serviced an area from The Spit in north Sydney to Maroubra and Bankstown.

Analysis of British “dark stores” by AT Kearny in 2013 found they can be three times more efficient than traditional supermarkets.

In a traditional supermarket, staff must negotiate trolleys around customers, check out queues and promotional set ups to gather goods for online orders, the report found. In contrast, “dark stores” are laid out for optimal efficiency.

Coles’ announcement comes just weeks after The New Daily revealed global e-commerce giant Amazon was planning to launch its online grocery service AmazonFresh in Australia by 2017 or early 2018.

Coles online only ‘divisive’

CQU online shopping expert Dr Li did not expect the trend to eradicate physical stores, but said it was a potentially profitable tactic for supermarkets.

“Some product categories are not that online friendly,” Dr Li told The New Daily.

“For example, if you consider products you need to touch and feel for its quality, those kind of products are less online shopping friendly.

“If you look at shoppers in supermarkets, half will be ones who like to touch their products and the other half won’t.

“So this kind of online shopping would not suit all customers.”

But for the estimated 50% of customers who do not want to touch or smell products, the “dark store” concept could be lucrative.

“The convenience factor for people in high density areas with a lot of traffic will be high though,” Dr Li said.

“Consumers value ease of processing quite highly. When it is easier to get a product, consumers’ opinion of a brand will increase.”

 Anthony Colangelo is a reporter for The New Daily, where this article was first published


Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
the wordmistress
6 years ago

Frankly, I see the merit. I do most of my grocery shopping online because it spares me quadruple handling of every product in the process of getting it from shelf to kitchen. I don’t enjoy grocery shopping and would rather spend my time on things I do enjoy. These days, businesses must do all they can to stay ahead of the competition, and all they can to delight customers. Fifty per cent is an enormous proportion of grocery shoppers to consider. I’ll be watching this with interest.

Robert Latchford
Robert Latchford
5 years ago

Makes sense in the areas with higher population density. Hope they employ people and not robots. Worrying trend is seeing less personal touch in stores and the supermarkets were once a good place for people to get an income – now the self checkouts are taking away that opportunity. New World in NZ are going the opposite way and have packers on tills – you pay a bit more but it is a more ‘human’ experience.

SmartCompany Plus

Sign in

To connect a sign in method the email must match the one on your SmartCompany Plus account.
Or use your email
Forgot your password?

Want some assistance?

Contact us on: or call the hotline: +61 (03) 8623 9900.