Former Coles employee awarded $1 million after falling off stool at work


By Elizabeth Byrne.

Coles Supermarkets has been ordered to pay more than $1 million to a former worker injured after she fell off a safety step.

The 34-year-old woman had only been working at the Canberra store for about a month in 2009 when she fell while straightening shelves.

The ACT Supreme Court heard she fell on her right side injuring her hip, and after several bouts of medical treatment the hip had to be replaced.

The woman told the court she had no training in using the step and had simply copied what another worker had done.

Lawyers for Coles told the court the safety step was used by supermarkets across Australia, and was an obvious piece of equipment for which no training was required.

But Justice Linda Ashford did not agree.

“The main thrust of the plaintiff’s submissions is that the plaintiff was not trained, or properly trained, in the use of the step,” she wrote.

“Calling a step a safety step does not make it so.”

Lawyers for Coles also suggested the woman had not been as badly hurt as she said.

But Justice Ashford rejected their argument in favour of the woman.

“The defendant submits the plaintiff to be exaggerating her symptoms,” she wrote.

“I did not believe the plaintiff to be other than straightforward in her evidence.

“Clearly this has been a significant injury and the plaintiff will have continuing problems with her hip, leading almost inevitably to further hip replacement surgery.”

She found Coles was liable for the accident.

“I am satisfied the risk of harm was reasonably foreseeable, and the risk was not insignificant,” she said.

Justice Ashford awarded the woman $1,088,468.53 in compensation, with $570,229 to cover past and future economic loss, $222,200 in general damages and $236,039 for past and future medical expenses.


This article was first published by The New Daily. You can read it here


Notify of
1 Comment
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
4 years ago

Wow, a step is very easy to use. Is no one responsible for themselves anymore.

If this was an SME they would be out of business. The value is huge.

I know someone who had a rock thrown from the blades from a slasher , he was 20+metre away and he had those clear face guards on, doing other work. It broke his jaw and it damaged his neck and they had a spinal fusion , after a vertebrae in the spine was taken out and put into the neck. He got $550K, he cannot get a job anymore.

It really makes me mad, some people get huge payouts for some low level injuries and the person i know who injury was extremely serious gets less.

I would also demand bone density testing, as I would not be surprised she has lower bone density. I suspect there was pre-existing problems.