Advertising watchdog upholds complaint against Thirsty Camel radio ad poking fun at supermodels
Friday, February 19, 2016/
Bottleshop chain Thirsty Camel has pulled a radio ad after the advertising watchdog ruled the commercial contravened prevailing community standards about health and safety by poking fun at supermodels.
The decision comes almost a year after the chain was reprimanded for depicting unsafe use of powerpoints.
The latest radio ad featured a female voiceover that equated a bottle of water with a “supermodel’s lunch”.
“They say there’s no such thing as a free lunch. Not true. Because right now, at Thirsty Camel, we’re giving away a gourmet supermodel’s lunch. That is, a refreshingly free bottle of water,” the person said.
The advertisement ran on radio station Nova FM from December to January, and was part of a promotion to give away 40,000 bottles of free water bottles at Thirsty Camel bottle shops in Victoria.
However, the Advertising Standards Board received a complaint that claimed the ad made light of eating disorders and was derogatory to models.
“Disordered eating should not be prompted, mocked or taken lightly, it deeply affects many peoples life,” the complainant wrote.
“The ad perpetuates negative views of the modelling industry which are no longer representative of the majority of super models. This ad is a form of ridicule and promotes body shaming.”
Thirsty Camel responded to the complaint, stating that two of the company’s core values are irreverence and fun, which is reflected in their advertising.
“The advert in question uses satire to reference dated stereotypes about supermodels; however at no point in time do we use language that is discriminatory, exploitative, degrading or demeaning as suggested by the complaint,” the company said.
In making their decision, a minority of members of the Advertising Standards Board noted the association between drinking water for lunch and being a model is “an out-dated notion”, saying most members of the public would interpret the ad as a “tongue-in-cheek reference which does not encourage or condone eating disorders”.
However the board ultimately noted that even using humour still validated the myth that models survive on water and little food.
“The overall message implies that it is okay for models to replace food with water and therefore if you want to be a model then this is acceptable behaviour,” the board said.
As a result, the board ruled the ad breached the section of the advertising industry code of conduct that specifies advertising must not depict material that is contrary to prevailing community standards, with reference to community views on healthy eating and body image.
Independent brand thinker and advisor Michel Hogan told SmartCompany this morning she believes this is another example of companies using “lazy” advertising.
“Companies keep doing this stupid stuff and it’s just lazy,” she says.
“There’s plenty of ways you can promote what you do and what you’re selling without basically falling back on laziness and innuendo.”
“Thirsty Camel or their agency – spend a bit more time thinking about what you’re putting out there and thinking a little more about the potential pros and cons about what you’re putting out there.”
Hogan agrees with the Ad Standards Board’s decision, describing the ad as “tasteless”, and says small businesses should attempt to bring a consciousness and deliberate thought process to marketing campaigns.
“If you’re a small business, to avoid lazy advertising think about what you stand for, think about what you care about and then think about what you’re trying to promote and connect those things together so you can use your advertising as a way of illustrating to your customers what you care about,” she says.
Jonathan Correll, senior manager at marketing communications firm Belles and Whistles says brands need to be careful when using humour, telling SmartCompany trying to be funny can often be a risky move.
“Often there are some brands that use irreverent humour as a key part of their advertising but it is becoming more difficult as sensitivity of social issues increases,” he says.
“Whilst a lot of people would see this is a harmless throwaway line, there are some who would definitely see the harm in this ad.”
SmartCompany contacted Thirsty Camel but did not receive a response prior to publication.
Social media mishaps: Why businesses should think twice before cracking jokes online Catriona Pollard CP Communications founder
An ‘opportunity-hunting’ generation: Here's what millennial workers need and want Karen Gately Corporate Dojo founder
Spilling the beans: Why inviting someone to 'grab a coffee' is disingenuous and unnecessary Sue Parker DARE Group founder
The 10 most unemployable job titles on LinkedIn Ian Whitworth Scene Change co-founder
How Emily McWaters manages her Sydney-based business from Kangaroo Island Emily McWaters The Hamper Emporium chief
Why 'Orwellian' performance monitoring is crucial to building an ethical company culture Michael Kodari Kodari Securities chief