Two golden rules: How to improve your LinkedIn conversion


Like you, I get a lot of LinkedIn requests. What surprises me is how many first messages are blatant sales pitches — and bad ones at that. If you use LinkedIn for prospecting, here are some tips on how to get it right so an annoyed new connection doesn’t block you.


Your first message makes or breaks the relationship. It’s a good idea to send your new connection a note within a couple of days, but not within minutes (unless it is merely to say ‘thanks for the connection’). Why? A fast reply can signal either desperation on your part or that they are just another cog in the request factory. There is an exception to this, which I’ll get to in a second.

In this first exchange, hold off on any action that requires a commitment of time or money on their behalf (such as a phone call, making a booking or buying now). You haven’t earnt it yet; ensure you give before you get. A no obligation gift (such as a trial, free resource or idea) is a better bet.

Here’s an example of a Lead Generation firm asking me for a phone call. I’m guessing they get a very poor response rate to this particular request.

About you not them

This is where most prospecting messages go wrong: they’re all about themselves rather than the person they are connecting with. Here’s the hot tip: most people like to hear about themselves, and will only be curious about you if you are curious about them first.

That’s the exception to the timing rule, by the way. You can send them a message soon after the connection, but only if articulates why you found their profile or business intriguing. It cannot be generic garbage either, it has to sound sincere and like you couldn’t wait to find out more about them.

The next example from a broker shows us what not to do in this regard.

How to get it right

Open the note by using their name; thank them for their connection; express an interest in their business or profile (‘I noticed you …’ or ‘I saw on your website …’); offer an insight into some aspect of their industry (‘I’ve noticed there’s a gap in how most businesses …’); and finally, ask for their grace to accept your offer of a gift (‘I hope you don’t mind …” or ‘something I thought you’d be interested in …’).

Keep it light and curious. If you are curious about them, they’ll be curious about you.

NOW READ: What does your LinkedIn photo say about you?

NOW READ: “Unbelievably concerning and creepy”: This entrepreneur is donating $1 every time she receives harassment on LinkedIn


Notify of
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
SmartCompany Plus

Sign in

To connect a sign in method the email must match the one on your SmartCompany Plus account.
Or use your email
Forgot your password?

Want some assistance?

Contact us on: or call the hotline: +61 (03) 8623 9900.