In a world where business leaders are increasingly accepting emotional intelligence and psychometric testing with open arms, Robert Spillane stands out as a lone dissenting voice.
Spillane, a professor at Macquarie Graduate School of Management and author of The Rise of Psycho Management in Australia, believes that the increasing use of office psychology has been severely detrimental to Australian businesses.
“It’s been a complete and utter disaster,” he says. “It’s undermined traditional management and it has undermined office performance.”
Get daily business news.
The latest stories, funding information, and expert advice. Free to sign up.
There is a push in Australian business to bring psychology into the office in a range of different forms, from in-house counselling to selection testing. Professor Spillane thinks that we’re going down a dangerous path.
“Managers are shoving their noses into places where they’re not needed. Management by personality has insinuated itself into our companies,” he says.
Spillane thinks that that the problem is becoming part of Australian business culture.
“There’s a view in Australia that people have to get along with each other, whereas in America it’s more about performance. People who are bringing in results are getting into trouble because they lack emotional intelligence.” Just recently, the CEO of Boral, Mark Selway, was pushed out of his role not for his performance, but for his style (see Mutiny on the good ship Boral).
A report released yesterday by the Inspire Foundation said that workplaces lost $237 million a year because of sick days taken and productivity lost due to mental illness among employees. In its recommendations it suggested that employers gain a better understanding of their employees’ mental health and how they could support them.
Spillane made a different diagnosis about what was affecting productivity in Australia.
The problem these days is that researchers are confusing stress into mental illness, he says. “There’s certainly a link between stress and productivity. Sick days caused by stress cost the community a lot of money.”