“Feel Great – lubricate!” employee poster sees Sydney Water hit with sex discrimination claim: Businesses warned over provocative ads
Thursday, September 28, 2017/
A Sydney Water worker says she was not shown the final version a workplace safety campaign she had agreed to be involved with, and was humiliated to discover a poster about spine safety was distributed across the workplace carrying her picture and the slogan, “Feel Great – lubricate!”
Thirty-nine year old Reem Yelda has lodged a complaint with then New South Wales Anti-Discrimination Board over the campaign, claiming Sydney Water and the subcontractor involved with the campaign, Vitality Works, breached the state’s Anti-Discrimination Act with the posters.
Yelda, who has worked for Sydney Water for more than a decade, says she was turned into “the punchline for a dirty joke” in the final version of a poster for the ‘SafeSpine’ campaign, which included a large slogan above an image of her with her arm in the air, which read “Feel great – lubricate!”
“Kick off your SafeStarts by warming up the joints,” the poster advises.
Slater and Gordon are representing Yelda in the complaint and principal Aron Neilson said in a statement his client took part in the project with good intentions, but was humiliated.
“She trusted this would be respectfully handled, but instead, she became the laughing stock of her workplace,” he said.
A spokesperson for Sydney Water has confirmed to SmartCompany that while the Anti-Discrimination Board has asked both parties to keep the details of the complaint confidential, Sydney Water believes “that the poster was not conduct of a sexual nature, but a work, health and safety campaign”.
Vitality Works, which operates the SafeSpine project and worked with Sydney Water on the poster design, confirmed to SmartCompany this morning that the poster is just one part of a broader campaign on spinal health. The company declined to give further comment on the sex discrimination claim, citing the board’s request for confidentiality.
Get final approval from staff for campaigns
Jess van der Walt, talent leader at Employsure, says given that marketing campaigns can evolve so quickly, it’s important for employers to keep any employees who might be involved in promotions in the loop about how things are changing.
“It’s very much about explaining and making clear what the end product will be,” van der Walt says.
There are basic brief points that businesses can follow, including keeping staff updated on “imagery, wording, slogans and the certain channels in which it [the material] going to be pushed out on,” van der Wilt says.
Advertising expert and senior lecturer at the University of Melbourne, Dr Lauren Rosewarne, says there’s temptation for companies to get provocative with their communications, but cases like this one suggest care should be taken.
“As both a writer and a reader, we want words to jump off the page: to be evocative and, particularly in the context of advertising, to get attention,” she says.
“‘Lubricate’ works this way. The word, however, also has connotations that we associate with sex, which means a slogan that might work effectively in a text-only poster, takes on different connotations when it is coupled with an employee photo.”
Rosewarne says that regardless of intentions, this case illustrates how a word that otherwise might be okay to use to advertise spine health can potentially cause concern within an employment environment by becoming “personalised and sexualised”.
For businesses looking to run their own internal marketing, Rosewarne emphasises the importance of employees seeing the final versions of any material they are featured in.
“This serves as a reminder to anyone agreeing to be involved in such messaging that it is essential to retain final approval of use of your image to avoid situations like this,” she says.
Amantha Imber runs a successful business — but she still has impostor syndrome Amantha Imber Inventium founder
Your future customers: How to crack the gen Z code Simon Slade Affilorama co-founder
Four stupid business decisions that burnt through $1 million Ian Whitworth Scene Change co-founder
Why corporate content will send your customers running Luke Buesnel Story League director
How to write the perfect job advertisement Alex Hattingh Employment Hero chief people officer
How to outshine the millions of websites ranking poorly on Google Adam Rowles Inbound Marketing founder