Hunting for dragons: Why the second ‘valley of death’ is the biggest problem facing the Australian startup ecosystem
Thursday, March 24, 2016/
The later-stage funding gap is now the second ‘valley of death’ for Australian startups and poses a serious risk for the entire ecosystem, OneVentures CEO Michelle Deaker says.
While most of the government’s $1 billion innovation statement focused on encouraging investors to back early-stage companies, Deaker says the attention now needs to turn to making sure startups with a proven product and defined market opportunity can find the necessary funding to grow within Australia.
This is the “most critical” stage in a startup’s life, Deaker says.
“There’s a yawning gap with later-stage funding in Australia,” Deaker tells StartupSmart.
“That’s when a startup is looking to scale rapidly. There’s market opportunity to capture and if they just grow organically they’re going to miss it.”
With the government’s tax incentives for early-stage startup investors soon to come into effect, it’s important that later-stage funding is also available when these companies grow, Deaker says.
“We’re going to have a groundswell of young, exciting and innovative companies and it’ll be about the next market gap,” she says.
“There’s a lot of activity at the lower end of the market with angel funding. We’re able to provide a lot of support for young companies but what happens when they grow up.”
A lack of competition
OneVentures, with its $100 million Innovation and Growth Fund II launching last year, is one of the few VC firms in Australia offering large later-stage funding between $5-20 million to local startups.
“There are very few places to get that sort of funding,” Deaker says.
“We don’t see a lot of competition.”
OneVentures has just closed a near-$20 million investment in an Australian biotech company, a move which Deaker says ensures that vital and lucrative technology is commercialised onshore.
The capital injection is in Clinical Genomics, a company set to launch proprietary next-generation blood-based diagnostic tools for detecting cancer. The funding will be used to advance the commercialisation of the technology which was developed in conjunction with the CSIRO.
“It’s an example of us funding to help companies get through this second ‘valley of death’,” Deaker says.
“They needed to raise a bigger round of funding to be able to take new products or expand services into new markets or geographies.
“OneVentures fills that gap and provides companies with a serious amount of capital.
“It’s a great outcome for Australia. This is a company that’s achieving the objectives in Malcolm Turnbull’s innovation statement.”
Increasing the brain drain
The much-talked about brain drain of Australian startups relocating overseas will only worsen unless more large rounds like this are available locally, Deaker says.
“This is when we see companies go offshore and become US companies,” she says.
Not having the adequate funding readily available will also mean many local startups may never reach their true potential, she says.
“If a company grows organically and slowly then it will never really achieve what it could have achieved,” Deaker says.
“The sad part about Australia is we often don’t get the outcomes we should out of the technology we create.
“We don’t understand the value of the technology we have.”
To combat the lack of funding, some companies may choose to list on the ASX before they’re ready, with very real consequences, Deaker says.
“That looks great initially but they will become a company in the land of the walking dead,” she says.
“They won’t be able to raise more capital and they won’t have any analyst support.”
And she says that there’s a role for government to play in fixing this problem.
“The government used to provide matching capital to help firms raise additional capital and those programs are really worthwhile for the country,” Deaker says.
“It’s about helping new venture firms get off the ground and helping them raise and expand funds.
“The role for government is to fill that quantum gap. If Treasury gets their money back then I can’t see the country having any issue.”
Deaker also says the government could relax the eligibility criteria for the tax incentives that were revealed in last year’s innovation statement to include larger, later-stage companies.
Hunting for dragons
While most of the discussion around startup investment is centred on finding the next billion dollar unicorn, Deaker says it really should be about finding the next “dragon”.
“Everyone talks about unicorns – companies worth more than a billion dollars even if they’re not sustainable,” she says.
“But from a fund manager’s perspective, one day you might love to get a unicorn so long as it can be beneficiary for you, but as an early investor you can get crushed when the unicorn gets big.
“What we really want are companies that can potentially return the whole of the fund. We invest, we back them heavily and the amount of capital you get will pay back all of the fund – that’s a dragon.”
And OneVentures has already hunted down its first dragon, with an investment from its first fund into biotech startup Hatchtech seeing a near-$280 million exit that paid back the entire fund.
There’s more to come too, Deaker says.
“We may well have another company that could also do that,” she says.
“That’s simply a fantastic outcome.”
A cultural war: What Hayne's report means for fintechs, accountants and small-business lending Charlotte Petris Timelio founder
In a perfect world: Canva's Melanie Perkins dreams about the future of Australian startups Melanie Perkins Canva co-founder
Swipe right for (data) validation: What dating apps can teach us about data security Leah Callon-Butler intimate.io co-founder
How do Australian startups tap into the $140 billion of dry powder sitting in the US? Andrea Kowalski Bailador partner
No silver bullet: Four steps to find the perfect sales and marketing channel for your startup Vinne Schifferstein Vidal Botown founder
Buzinga to Appster: An insider's theory on why the app giants keep falling Joseph Russell DreamWalk Apps co-founder
Got brand goals? The four most marketable sports of 2019 Andrew Montesi Pickstar head of marketing
What founders can do now to prepare for a possible 2019 recession Les Szekely EVP co-founder