Scientists take to Twitter to ground Elon Musk’s Mars settlement vision


SpaceX founder Elon Musk had his Twitter account hacked last week.

Astrobiologist Caleb Scharf has made international headlines for criticising Elon Musk’s “Battlestar Galactica”-like plans to settle shiploads of people on Mars in the next three decades.

To set the scene, the SpaceX founder took to Twitter last week to reveal he is “accumulating assets on Earth” to allow “life to become multiplanetary” in the next few decades.

In his tweets, Musk said sending one million people to Mars by 2050 would be possible provided we begin the production of 1,000 spacecrafts in the next 10 years. He plans to launch three of these “Starships” every day.

Musk went on to describe his vision of a Mars settlement, including how the high supply of Mars-based jobs would also allow passengers to pay off the “loans available for those who don’t have money”.

Scharf responded to what he described as Musk’s “provocative fashion” in an article for Scientific American, pointing out the “martian radiation environment” would endanger the lives of would-be human explorers.

“To put all of this another way: in the worst-case scenario (which may or may not be a realistic extrapolation) there’s a chance you’d end up dead or stupid on Mars. Or both,” Scharf wrote.

“Obviously no one, not even an emboldened SpaceX, is going to plop humans down on Mars en masse without worrying about all of this.”

Canadian astrophysicist Katie Mack supported Scharf’s concerns, adding the lack of planetary magnetic fields would require humans to seek out deep, inhospitable caves for shelter.

“There is virtually nothing we — or the Universe — could do to Earth that would make it less habitable than Mars. Global warming, nuclear winter, extinction-level asteroid… still easier to live in caves here than there,” Mack said.

The exchange follows SpaceX’s successful test of its Crew Dragon capsule’s emergency escape systems for NASA, during which it intentionally destroyed one of its Falcon 9 rockets.

“As far as we can tell, it was a picture-perfect mission,” Musk said in a press conference following the test.

NOW READ: Thanks Elon: How SpaceX has lowered launch costs and made space more accessible

NOW READ: Elon Musk’s SpaceX has launched 60 satellites in pursuit of faster internet — but stargazers aren’t happy about it


Notify of
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
2 years ago

I wonder if people realise what a least 500000 rooms look like. If the average people are in a relationship and are a couple and possibly with kids. Then imagine sealed off from it’s atmosphere on another planet. I have an idea or concept for a room, smaller than a dorm room, would still seem about the size of a dorm room. The main aspect is that it would have less volume than a dorm room for single people or kids. Less volume would add up on major scale like colonizing a planet. Would also work well for on an ocean ship, new dorm room versions and other structures. It’s possible to put an individual desk and chair past the bed and still be smaller than most rooms.

2 years ago

I have a list of people I’d like to send to Mars.

SmartCompany Plus

Sign in

To connect a sign in method the email must match the one on your SmartCompany Plus account.
Or use your email
Forgot your password?

Want some assistance?

Contact us on: or call the hotline: +61 (03) 8623 9900.