Business slammed for offering bushfire donations in exchange for Facebook ‘likes’
Friday, January 11, 2013/
Businesses have once again been warned not to mix charity and commercial business on Facebook after an online business in Queensland has been forced to retract a campaign to donate electrical generators to the victims of Tasmania bushfires for every “like” it receives on its main page.
This isn’t the first time such a controversy has occurred – two years ago during the Queensland floods, electronics retailer Bing Lee was slammed for a similar proposal.
And only last year, carmaker Kia was heavily criticised for its Facebook ‘likes for food’ campaign, in which the Korean company promised to make donations to World Vision in exchange for Facebook likes.
“At the end of the day, companies have a responsibility, both economic and social,” says Retail Doctor Group managing director Brian Walker.
“When the waters get muddied like that, it has the effect of invading the social case of a brand, or confusing the two. And that’s why you don’t see high performing, trusted brands doing that sort of thing.”
The incidents highlight the growing difficulty for businesses in managing online campaigns – many see the opportunity to comment on current events, but often veer too close to touchy subjects.
Queensland company SellItOnline originally said on its Facebook page that it would donate electric generators to Tasmanian bushfire victims for every “like” of its page. The company received backlash from its 1,500 fans, accusing the company of taking advantage of the catastrophe.
The company was contacted this morning, but no reply was received prior to publication. In a statement provided to SmartCompany, the business said it was “very sorry if anyone was offended by this”.
“The post was removed ASAP as SellItOnline didn’t want to upset anyone. All SellItOnline wanted to do is help the people in Tasmania.”
The business has already donated one generator to a Tasmanian man.
This type of slip-up has happened before. Customers don’t usually take too kindly to being coerced into liking a page, just because the company in question wants to donate some money.
When Bing Lee started a similar campaign, it pledged to donate $1 to the Queensland flood appeal for every user who became a member. Users started even using a hashtag: “#charityfail”.
Of course, the company didn’t even back down. It defended the statement on its Facebook page saying “this has been a good outcome”.
But the practice goes against the advice of many social media consultants, who say mixing charity and business never goes well when you’re getting something out of it.
“The idea of a charity, or the idea of giving to a social cause, is used because it fits with the brand and the brand’s social conscience,” says Brian Walker. “It’s tacky.”
Walker says the most important point to note is that these types of campaigns “confuse the brand”.
“It just doesn’t really seem to provide the brand with any sort of value,” he says.
This story first appeared on SmartCompany.
From the frontlines
Alan Jones: How to raise investment for a startup with no customers and no revenue Alan Jones M8 Ventures partner
Canva's Melanie Perkins has 10 tips for startups with 'crazy-big dreams' Melanie Perkins Canva co-founder
Why Up's transgender controversy shows there can be no separation between founders and their companies Joan Westenberg StartupSmart columnist
Take a stand: Why being neutral hurts profitability and engagement Steven Maarbani VentureCrowd executive director
The power of passion: Naked Wines' co-founder reflects on what made the startup successful Peta Jecks Naked Wines co-founder
Hipsters, hustlers and hackers: Three instances of everyday bias in startupland Theresa Lim Play2Lead founder
Diversity and coaching will rid the banking sector of its toxic culture problem Hema Kangeson inSpur founder
Why you should find the right role for the right person — not the other way around Bruce Stronge Outfit founder